“When we work on making our devices accessible by the blind, I don’t consider the bloody ROI.”
That’s Apple CEO Tim Cook, speaking at the company’s annual shareholder meeting in February, after a representative of conservative think tank National Center for Public Policy Research asked a question related to a shareholder proposal that would have Apple disclosing the exact costs of its environmental sustainability programs and industry participation.
Cook would go on to say that the sentiment applied to environmental issues, worker safety and other areas, reported Bryan Chaffin of The Mac Observer. Cook then directly addressed the representative, saying bluntly, “If you want me to do things only for ROI reasons, you should get out of this stock.”
The whole account is actually pretty telling when it comes to the way Cook thinks about how Apple uses its resources — and it’s a bit refreshing, to be honest.
But it got me thinking about other areas where Apple could stand to “not consider the bloody ROI” when it comes to serving their customers. One that jumped to mind immediately was iCloud storage — specifically with relation to photos.
Currently, you get a very meager 5GB for free when you purchase an iOS device. You can then upgrade it (for a fairly hefty sum) all the way up to 50GB for $100.
Back when the shareholder meeting happened, I tweeted that Cook should perhaps ignore whatever return on investment that Apple hoped to get from iCloud storage, and got a pretty strong response. Many good points were made in the comments, including the fact that you can’t even buy enough storage to back up a single 64GB device — and Apple already sells units with as much as 128GB of storage.
But, even more than backups of anything else, this is really about photos. Ask your average iOS user what is taking up the most storage on their device and it’s almost guaranteed to be photos. Apple has spent billions making the iPhone one of the best and most-used pocket cameras in the world — but its storage policies punish the most prolific photographers.
Consistently, when I speak to users about their iOS device woes, it comes down to running out of space for photos and video. And photos differ significantly from other data in that there is an intense emotional and mnemonic attachment to them. These are fragments of life, not just packets of data.
That’s why I think that this year would be a really fine time for Apple to start ignoring the ROI of iCloud storage. Here’s what might be a good move:
Make everyone’s iPhoto library live in iCloud, period. Having to rely on the hinky, complex behavior of iCloud photo stream and remembering to launch iPhoto on a Mac to back up photos is silly. The moment you shoot a photo it should save it on your device and upload a low-res version to iCloud. And the moment you connect to Wi-Fi it should upload the full-res version, period. All of your photos, in iCloud, done.Make iCloud backup free with purchase of a device. Not a certain amount of storage, just ‘enough’ to back up whatever is on your device. Simple.
Now, I am not blind to the fact that cloud storage is not free, not even for Apple. There will be a significant cost factor to implementing these measures. But that’s where ‘ignoring’ the ROI comes in.
But, if any company is capable of making a decision that prioritizes intangibles in the service of customer delight, it’s Apple. And they’ve consistently benefited from those kinds of decisions over the past decade with real, tangible sales and repeat business.
If it’s a matter of money, I think it’s hard to argue that the ongoing costs of server maintenance, power and upkeep are eating into Apple’s still-growing cash piles. And the way I see it, this fits in with moves like making OS X and iWork free for purchasers of Apple hardware. If it’s purely a matter of storage capacity, well they’re building data centers like crazy, so they’ll have enough space soon enough. Even so, serving the first item right now might actually be more feasible than the second item. So, photos now, which are the most important items, and everything else once they have enough capacity.
I’ve been hearing that Apple is working on photo-related announcements for WWDC, and that all of the teams working on Photos, iPhoto and Aperture are finally unified under one group now. Hopefully this means that photos, and iCloud storage, will get some nice face time during the keynote next month. I have no idea if they will for sure, but they should.
IMAGE BY Flickr USER Angelo DeSantis UNDER CC BY 2.0 LICENSE
Anonymous apps like Secret and Whisper are all the rage right now and maybe that shouldn’t be a surprise. This feels like the inevitable reaction to all the major social networks wanting to own our identities — preferably with our real names attached.
What they are getting, however, is the completely boring and sanitized version of us. The one where everybody is happy and is on an eternal, Instagram-friendly beach vacation. Where the kids are always happy, all the babies are cute and the party never ends. Because we don’t want to create any controversy, we mostly keep our real thoughts hidden and just publish photos from airports, beaches and birthday parties.
In the early days, the Internet promised us anonymity, but now we know that all of our moves are tracked by somebody. If it’s not the NSA, it’s Google or another advertising company that wants to create a profile of our every move.
Whenever you know you are being tracked, you will inevitably change your behavior, even if it’s just subconsciously. When you know your family members and all of your friends will see what you’re doing, you definitely change your behavior and think about every word in your status update.
And that’s why there is this fascination with anonymous apps. They give us the kind of experience we expect from modern social networks without any of the social baggage. They let us say something we know people will disagree with and we still have a job on Monday (or we may just find others agree with us, too). They let us talk about our depressions, illnesses, bowel movements and bedroom habits, and will provide us with honest feedback — even if it hurts.
Of course, there is a dark side, too, and it’s pretty dark. In schools, anonymous apps are making it easy for even the most outwardly shy student to become a bully, and even the best discussion can be undermined by anonymous trolls. Nobody is safe and we (and the developers behind apps like Yik Yak) will have to figure out ways for dealing with this or this whole phenomenon is going to be very short-lived.
The reality, of course, is that you are not anonymous to the anonymity apps. They may even end up knowing more about you than anybody else and they will inevitably try to cash in on this. Thankfully, none of these apps have made blackmail their business models yet, but there is a treasure trove of data for advertisers in their databases.
Unless you want to risk going to 4chan, though, this new breed of apps allows us to be our online selves again — and leaving aside all the other (and very real) concerns around bullying and false gossip, that feels pretty freeing. Google, Facebook and all the other players in this field want to own our online identities and have made us sanitize our feeds. There is some use for that, but it’s only natural that there is a pushback now.
window.__o = {"channel":"entertainment","content_type":"article","v_buy":null,"v_buy_i":null,"h_pub":5.0,"h_buy":null,"h_pub_buy":null,"v_cur":0.8,"v_max":1.2,"v_cur_i":0,"v_max_i":1,"events":"event51,event61","top_channel":"entertainment","content_source_type":"Internal","content_source_name":"Internal","author_name":"Alex Magdaleno","age":"0","pub_day":26,"pub_month":5,"pub_year":2014,"pub_date":"05/26/2014","isPostView":true,"post_lead_type":"BC Video Lead","topics":"3D glasses,3d movies,Entertainment,Film,Gadgets,Uncategorized,Videos","campaign":null,"display_mode":null}; window._gaq = window._gaq || []; window._gaq.push(['_setAccount', 'UA-92124-1']);With These 3D Glasses, You're in Charge of Your Movie-Watching ExperienceMashableMashableSign inLikeFollow @mashablesee more >SearchMust ReadsSocial MediaTechBusinessEntertainmentUS & WorldWatercoolerMoreChannelsMust ReadsSocial MediaTechBusinessEntertainmentUS & WorldWatercoolerCompanyAbout UsLicensing & ReprintsArchiveMashable CareersContactContact UsSubmit NewsAdvertiseAdvertiseLegalPrivacy PolicyTerms of UseAppsiPhone AppiPad AppAndroid AppResourcesSubscriptionsSitesJobsEventsSocial Good SummitMedia SummitEntertainmentLikeFollowWith These 3D Glasses, You're in Charge of Your Movie-Watching Experience
window.__o = {"channel":"tech","content_type":"article","v_buy":null,"v_buy_i":null,"h_pub":6.5,"h_buy":null,"h_pub_buy":null,"v_cur":1.0,"v_max":1.0,"v_cur_i":1,"v_max_i":1,"events":"event51,event61","top_channel":"tech","content_source_type":"Internal","content_source_name":"Internal","author_name":"Armand Valdes","age":"0","pub_day":25,"pub_month":5,"pub_year":2014,"pub_date":"05/25/2014","isPostView":true,"post_lead_type":"YouTube Video Lead","topics":"Android TV,Apple TV,Apps and Software,Ask A Dev,chromecast,Dev & Design,Gadgets,Google,mashable video,Mobile,mobile minute,Tech,Uncategorized,xbox one","campaign":null,"display_mode":null}; window._gaq = window._gaq || []; window._gaq.push(['_setAccount', 'UA-92124-1']);Tech Companies Battle for a Spot in Your Living RoomMashableMashableSign inLikeFollow @mashablesee more >SearchMust ReadsSocial MediaTechBusinessEntertainmentUS & WorldWatercoolerMoreChannelsMust ReadsSocial MediaTechBusinessEntertainmentUS & WorldWatercoolerCompanyAbout UsLicensing & ReprintsArchiveMashable CareersContactContact UsSubmit NewsAdvertiseAdvertiseLegalPrivacy PolicyTerms of UseAppsiPhone AppiPad AppAndroid AppResourcesSubscriptionsSitesJobsEventsSocial Good SummitMedia SummitTechLikeFollowTech Companies Battle for a Spot in Your Living Room
Editor’s note: Matt Oguz is managing director of Palo Alto Venture Science.
When Nassim Nicholas Taleb developed his popular theory to explore way-out-of-the-norm surprising events, he outlined three characteristics of a black swan event:
The event has a huge impactThe event is very hard to explain using (commonly used) scientific methodsThe event appears unforeseen due to people’s psychological biases.
The black swan events are popular in venture capital, a unique asset class that historically has all three characteristics as Taleb outlined in his colorful book. What makes venture capital different from other asset classes is its complex qualitative and quantitative characteristics. The qualitative attributes are widely covered. The quantitative characteristics, not so much.
Numerical analysis had been more predominant in liquid assets such as stocks where historic returns are available. For example, if you put $50 in Google last year, you’d end up with $100 this year. You can see the same for AAPL or GE. From there, you can do a number of calculations such as overall returns in a portfolio made up of stocks or comparing their returns to a bundle of them, i.e. indexes.
Understanding returns and portfolio management concepts in liquid markets are quite clear thanks to Nobel Prize-winning economists such as Harry Markowitz. Unfortunately, Markowitz’s portfolio theory won’t work for venture capital because it turns out that VC returns are not normally distributed, a requirement for Markowitz to work.
For private companies, particularly in their early stages, numerical analysis is complex. The frame in which you look at startups is completely different from the one for liquid assets. Several years ago Fred Wilson started to explore in his blog what these returns look like. Taleb in his book calls the bell curve “that great intellectual fraud” and explains the situations that don’t demonstrate a bell curve. Unfortunately, he doesn’t dig deeper into what the non-bell curve looks like, and leads us to believe in a mystical situation that eventually leads to another cognitive bias: “nothing, particularly outliers, can be predicted, so let’s just focus on what we know.” On the contrary, non-Gaussian distributions are well-studied.
So a closer look at the distribution of returns in venture capital looks something like this:
Traditional VC targets home runs to compensate for early losses.
This looks quite like what’s called a lognormal curve. The distribution actually resembles more of a log-levy distribution, a variant of lognormal but let’s stick with lognormal for simplicity. Here’s the academic description: A random variable X is said to have the lognormal distribution with parameters µ?R and s?(0,8) if ln(X) has the normal distribution with mean µ and standard deviation s. Equivalently, X=eY where Y is normally distributed with mean µ and standard deviation s. The log of the random variable is normally distributed.
The lognormal distribution is used to model continuous random quantities when the distribution is believed to be skewed, such as certain income and lifetime variables. Only positive values are possible for the variable, and the distribution is skewed to the left (Gibrat, 1931). Limpert et al. has a great paper in this field named Lognormal Distributions across the Sciences: Keys and Clues. In that paper, Lambert et al. describe the characteristics of lognormal distribution beautifully and provide examples of lognormal events. Some of those are as follows:
Latency periods of diseasesSurvival time after cancer diagnosisCrystals in ice creamAge of marriage
Income distribution (quite a popular subject these days):
A random variable X is said to be lognormally distributed if log(X) is normally distributed. Lognormal curves describe the 80/20 situations better.
One may argue that the examples cited above don’t demonstrate extreme cases, i.e. black swans. But even in cases where “black swan” events exist, Benoit Mandelbrot, renowned professor of mathematical sciences at Yale, argued that log-levy distributions with longer tails are more appropriate.
The mathematical implications of the lognormal nature play into questions such as:
How much we deploy to each startup we fund, i.e. guidance for check sizesDry powder size i.e. cash reserves needed to make future investmentsNumber of investments to makeDistributing investments among funding stages
Elton and Gruber in their academic paper provide a good introduction to portfolio theory when investment relatives are lognormally distributed. If we assume that the returns are normal, and turns out they are not, then all of our calculations will be way off, including check size, re-ups, and dry powder. Analyzing returns based on their lognormal distribution characteristics provides great guidance to us and leads us to more rational decisions in how we deploy capital. As we start investing and realizing returns or losses, we’ll have a much better understanding of where the overall fund returns will end up. From there, we can adjust the size of our investments or bets.
The late John Lintner, a Nobel Prize winner and professor of economics at Harvard, showed in his earlier work that security and portfolio returns are better modeled by a lognormal distribution than a normal distribution. Levy, Bawa and Chakrin later showed that for lognormal distributions investors would choose their portfolios from a mean logarithmic variance efficient frontier. The lognormal nature of the returns provide good guidance for the downside of a portfolio as we construct the probability distribution for the entire portfolio by computing a series of convolution integrals.
The check-size problem for instance is common in venture capital. Let’s say a company is raising a $10 million round. How much do you participate? $2 million, $3 million, more? The real problem here is how to maximize gains based on the the assumption that we’ll make more of these investments, the size of our pool of capital and the probability distribution of returns and failures.
John Kelly, who worked at Bell Labs, developed Kelly Criterion in 1956 to tackle long distance telephone signal noise issues. Kelly later teamed up with Claude Shannon, who is famous for having founded information theory, digital computer and digital circuit design theories. Ed Thorpe, an MIT math-professor-turned-blackjack-player turned multibillion dollar hedge fund manager utilized Kelly Criterion to optimize his investment sizes in both blackjack and then in a “safer” gaming environment, the Wall Street. Thorpe’s blackjack adventure became the basis for the MIT blackjack team and made it to the big screen in the movie 21.
Unfortunately, Thorpe’s much more successful hedge fund did not receive popular coverage. PIMCO’s Bill Gross is also a huge proponent of Kelly Criterion and his accomplishments are stellar. Since we understand the nature of the returns, expanding Kelly to venture capital is quite possible. Solving a Kelly variant assuming a lognormal distribution helps drive rational answers to questions such as check size or dry powder calculations.
One major implication of the return multiples resembling a lognormal curve is that the more errors we make early in the game, the less likely we are to hit a homerun. On the qualitative end of this analysis, to get to better returns we must somehow cut the “excess fat” from the top of this curve and add it to the tail. It seems like if we can do that: a. our returns will improve and b. we’ll end up better prepared for a home-run.
Using decision models to have a disciplined selection process helps minimize cognitive errors. The VC industry is prone to “black swan” events due to its high propensity for cognitive biases, one of the three characteristics of a black swan.
Avoiding decision errors would certainly improve our returns, or “add alpha” as jargoned in finance. In an earlier article, I outlined a number of errors generally committed in venture capital such as anchoring, availability bias, recency, unit bias? — ?accepting valuations as “universal,” group thinking (bandwagon effect) — following the herd, cognitive inertia? — unwillingness to change thought patterns, irrational escalation? — re-upping investment even though one knows it’s a bad one, and overconfidence.
The presence of decision biases is one of the three characteristics of a black swan event.The other two are large impact of the event and not being able to model the probability of the event. So if we’re after a black swan, on the upside, avoiding cognitive errors earlier on should lead to thicker tails thereby increasing the chances of a home run.
Key venture capital decisions using analytics vs. (popular) heuristics.
The events on the end of the lognormal tail are where big return multiples are and their returns are substantially higher than average returns. Even though cognitive biases are common in venture capital decision-making, particularly in capital deployment, the benefits of a disciplined approach are clear. As we see looking at past returns, “soft” characteristics of fund management such as deal-flow, value-add, etc. have not delivered the 3x+ returns on a consistent basis regardless of the VC firm.
A comprehensive study of the economic nature of venture capital is a must in every VC firm from here on out. In our case, understanding the statistical distribution of returns provides guidelines around how we deploy capital instead of arbitrary rules-of-thumb.
As John Arbuthnot said, “Mathematical knowledge adds vigour to the mind, frees it from prejudice, credulity, and superstition” and as we build companies based on math and engineering every day, that is exactly where venture capital needs to be.
Yesterday, Google announced its finalists for the Bay Area Impact Challenge, its latest effort to assist nonprofits in the region through grants and support from Googlers willing to volunteer their time.
The company is letting anyone vote for their favorite nonprofits among the finalists. On June 3, it will announce which four received the most votes, and offer them each a $500,000 grant and access to a co-working space in San Francisco, and will encourage employees to volunteer for their causes.
I’ve spoken to the finalists to find out what the community would get out of Google’s grants and support. If you’re unsure who to vote for, this should help guide you to the nonprofit that will benefit the cause you care about most.
Health Trust – Among its efforts to enable healthier living, Health Trust operates food carts in SF that are strategically placed to let kids pick up healthy fruits and vegetables on their way home from school instead of stopping by a 7-Eleven and picking up a snack. With studies showing that nearly one-fourth of kids is malnourished, Health Trust’s goal is to double the number of youth it reaches through its cart program by increasing the number of carts and strategically placing them on common routes between schools and residential neighborhoods.
Community Music Center – The Community Music Center aims to make music accessible to people of all ages. With its application to the Bay Area Impact Challenge, it’s hoping to bring the benefits of music and community participation to those above the age of 60. In August 2012, the CMC partnered with the University of California, San Francisco, to research and document benefits of singing in community choir, starting with 12 different community choirs. If given the $500,000 grant, their choir program will be able to continue for a minimum of two years, impacting 400 choir participants and thousands of performance attendees each year. In addition to the grant, Google has offered to provide online marketing and analytics for the choir’s performances and assistance in the form of employees volunteering.
BUILD – BUILD targets schools with high drop-outs rates, low graduation rates, and low college acceptance rates. It provides mentors who, through deep engagement, teach entrepreneurial skills that help to not only get students through school but come out prepared for the real world. With the $500,000 grant from Google, the nonprofit would like to expand to San Francisco and San Jose from their current locations in Redwood City, Oakland and East Palo Alto. Currently, they serve 825 high school students in the Bay Area — their planned expansion would increase that 300 percent to 3,000. In addition to the grant money, Google has promised the nonprofit greater exposure to its employees, a huge promise considering the fact that the vast majority of its mentors come from corporate sponsors.
SubArt – With the grant from Google, SubArt wants to use art to bring “themed connectivity” to BART and MUNI stations throughout the Bay Area. It would put the money towards engaging the public in a dialogue, including hosting large workshops and paying research firms for polling and to conduct focus groups to identify which cultural factors bring residents of the Bay Area together. The benefits aren’t just aesthetic: Studies have shown that people will walk farther to/between public transit when they have engaging public art to consume as part of their commute.
Hack the Hood – Hack the Hood is a six-week summer program that teaches at-risk students technical skills and puts them to work for local businesses who can’t afford to hire technical employees full-time. The students receive $1,000 for their participation. Google’s grant would let the program expand from 20 to 100 students and let the nonprofit offer the program year round.
Mission Asset Fund – According to CEO José Quiñonez, the Mission Asset Fund currently partners with nine nonprofits in San Francisco and Alameda County to “formalize informal loans” — basically, reporting loans between friends to credit bureaus so that a small loan to help buy a bike can improve one’s credit score. Mission Asset Fund plans to use the $500,000 grant from Google to expand its partnerships to a total of 28 nonprofits and improve the technology behind its “Social Loans Platform,” built on Salesforce CRM.
Beyond 12 – Beyond 12 seeks to improve the higher-education outcomes of students across the country through a combination of data collection and mentorship. With the $500,000 grant from Google, the nonprofit would increase the number of students whose progress it tracks from 32,000 to 100,000 and the number of students it coaches from 2,000 to 10,000 in addition to rolling out a new mobile platform that will better facilitate both sides of its effort. In addition to the financial aid Beyond 12 would receive, Google would help by providing mobile developers (on a volunteer basis) to improve the mobile experience provided by its platform.
Pogo Park – Parks are an important cultural center in any city. They give those who live in urban areas a place to get some fresh air; children, a place to run around and play; and Millennials a place to walk their French bulldogs. Pogo Park plans to use the grant from Google to improve the parks and playgrounds in Richmond’s Iron Triangle in order to improve the health and well-being of thousands of at-risk children.
Bring Me A Book - One of the biggest keys to improving life-long academic success is instilling a love of reading at a young age. Bring Me A Book plans to use the grant from Google to provide libraries in the Bay Area with high-quality children’s books and read-aloud workshops for disadvantaged children.
Center for Employment Opportunities - CEO helps those who have been incarcerated break from the vicious cycle of the penal system and unemployment by providing “transitional employment” and job placement. With the grant from Google, the nonprofit would like to expand its employment program to 300 employees in Oakland and 200 in San Jose over the next two years, as well as place another 280 into paid jobs.